AMPS - Valve VS. Solid State

AVForums

Help Support AVForums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

PAPPA3

AVForums Grandmaster
*
AV Forums Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2010
Messages
3,700
Reaction score
370
Location
Randfontein, West rand
I?m quite impressed with a little NAD 3020A I picked up this week.  Impressive soundstage and clear mids and highs, a real spunky amp.  Made me think the whole solid state vs valve amp debate.  Anyone care to comment on their experiences ? preferably if you?ve had both types of amps.

Valve ? great mids and highs; little listening fatigue; a smooth listen.  I'm not impressed with bass though.  It?s big and it?s there, but a tad too spongy for me.

Solid state ? can do great mids and highs, but top end can get brittle; bass is tighter; prone to listening fatigue, especially if the room isn?t treated.

I know it all depends on the equipment under review, but these are general observations.  I?m beginning to think that I need to circumvent the whole matter to improve my set-up.  I?m thinking a good pair of standmounts (Monitor Audio Gold series standmounts ? I wish ;D) will give me good detail, with less bass overhang.  Anyone care to comment on your experience ? if you?ve had both types of amps.  Have you started with valve, tested solid state amps, and then gone back to valve, or vice versa?  If so, what were your reasons.
 
Top